A Parent’s Guide to School Options in NYC

A Parent’s Guide to School Options in NYC

Choosing a school for your child can happen anytime, not just at the start of the academic year. You may be planning for next school year, navigating a mid-year move, or looking for a new option as your child transitions from daycare to elementary school. Whether they’re moving up to middle school or simply in need of a better educational fit, it’s natural to worry about making the right decision.

In many areas in the country, traditional district public schools may be the best—and sometimes only option for kids. However, New York City families aren’t limited to traditional public schools; they can also explore charter, independent (private), magnet, and religious school options.

Psst… Check Out New NYC Budget Expands 2K Child Care, Boosts Special Needs Services, and Adds $220M in Child Care Vouchers

Each school type has advantages, and no single model is universally “better.” It’s about finding what fits your child and family best. Here’s a breakdown of the key options:

Charter Schools

Charter Schools are public schools with fewer regulations. They are tuition-free public schools funded by local, state, and federal funds, yet operate independently of district control. NYC has around 281 charter schools serving nearly 150,000 students (about 15% of total public enrollment).

“Charter schools do not have the same oversight as public schools, but they need to be partially funded by the public government. They can also seek funding elsewhere,” Mary Miele, CEO, Evolved Education Company, explains. “Charter schools can set their own curriculum, but they will be evaluated based on testing, which the public school also gives (the NYS exams in grades 3-8), and so the curriculum does involve a good amount of prep for those exams.”

According to the New York State Education Department, a significant difference between charter schools and traditional public schools is that charter schools often focus on innovative curricula, new approaches to school organization or instruction, or another feature that conventional public schools wouldn’t be able to accomplish without the flexibility given by a charter.

However, Miele says charter schools need to produce strong NYS test results to continue funding, as many are more traditional in their teaching approach and teach toward those tests.

Parents can learn more about charter schools, what a charter is, and other information at nysed.gov.

Independent Schools

Also known as private schools, independent schools are primarily funded by tuition and charitable donations rather than taxpayer dollars.

“Typically, independent schools do quite a bit of fundraising, and parents may be tasked with organizing some of it,” says Christine Hernandez, early childhood and parenting expert and founder of Allo Saratoga in New York State.

Independent schools are free to set their own curriculum and educational approach. A public entity does not review the curriculum.

The admission process for independent schools varies but generally involves several steps. This typically includes filling out an application, visiting the school for student and parent interviews, and potentially taking an entrance exam. Additionally, families may need to send in teacher recommendations and transcripts, write parent and student essays, and submit videos of the student, particularly for the kindergarten admission process.

Magnet Schools

Magnet schools are operated by the NYC Department of Education (DOE). They are tuition-free and publicly funded, partly through competitive Magnet Schools Assistance Program grant awards from the U.S. Department of Education. Magnet schools offer whole-school, specialized thematic programs in art, architecture, engineering, civics, leadership, exploration, global conservation, and STEM/STEAM, incorporating innovative curriculum and enrichment experiences designed to engage and inspire learning.

Magnet schools utilize diversified teaching approaches, including inquiry and project-based learning with real-world connections and authentic application of skills. Partnerships with colleges, universities, professional and community organizations, cultural institutions, and Artists in Residency programs provide professional development opportunities and supplement student and family experiences. The rigorous instructional foundation is supported and enhanced by instructional technology, dedicated spaces for arts and science, such as maker-spaces, horticultural labs, broadcast studios, STEM/STEAM activities, and special programs.

The admissions process for magnet schools involves a centralized application process, but no screening or testing is involved in applying. For more information, families should contact info@magnetschools.nyc or visit magnetschools.nyc.

Religious Schools

Religious schools across the city—including Catholic, Jewish, Muslim, Christian, and other faith-based institutions—prioritize both academic excellence and spiritual values. These schools aim to create nurturing environments that promote respect, service, and moral development, all while delivering a rigorous academic curriculum. Students typically study core subjects such as Math, English Language Arts, History, and Science, alongside faith-based education aligned with the school’s religious tradition.

Many religious schools have also embraced modern advancements, integrating technology and STEM programs to support a well-rounded education. For example, recent New York State Education Department Examination results confirm that Catholic schools in the Archdiocese of New York have once again outperformed both New York State and New York City public schools regarding performance growth.

Religious schools often appeal to families seeking a values-driven education supporting academic and personal development in a community setting.

Catholic Schools prioritize both academic excellence and Catholic values. Students are immersed in an environment that promotes respect, courtesy, and service to others, which are integral to their curriculum. These schools offer a comprehensive range of subjects, including Math, Religion, English Language Arts, History, and Science. Moreover, they have embraced modern technology in the classrooms and introduced STEM programs to foster a well-rounded education.

Recent New York State Education Department Examination results confirm that Catholic Schools in the Archdiocese of New York have once again outperformed both New York State and New York City schools regarding performance growth.

With such a diverse educational landscape, New York-area families are uniquely positioned to find a school that fits their child’s needs—whether that’s a values-driven religious education, the innovation of charter or magnet schools, or the tailored programming of an independent school.

Explore options by visiting school websites, attending open houses, and reviewing performance data (like test scores and diversity reports). Understanding application processes, like charter lotteries or private school testing, is also key.

Ultimately, the best choice is one where your child feels supported, engaged, and able to thrive. The search may take time, but discovering a school where your child can grow academically and personally is well worth the effort.

Psst… Check Out 2025 Guide to NYC Neighborhoods: Manhattan